Second Week Live-10 Guyes

Classics from the 70's...

Mike John....Ok I get it he likes tennis...Fleetwood Mac..Very pitchy and no energy..I think this guy thinks he has this won..flat in parts...He is not....7....Not good..Randy said not your best...Paula..said consistent..she is off on this...Simon said it was ok, your weakest, no moment and weak choice.....I think it sucked..

Jason Castro....The guy has no personality...Playing again...For So Long..Bee Gees..Nice take on the song..He has to emote more..His soul is in the song..sound like Iglesias...Good when it goes to the guitar..Its a good song..8...He is one of the final two guys...Randy said...It was just ok.....Paula said you are cute..said lets see you as an artist..Simon said it was horrible, did not suit the voice..Average choice of song..I agree with all of them..

Luke Minard....Guy creeps me out...Singing Queen...He is too calculated..Thinks he is the other dude from the other season..Not a strong voice, too nasal...I think he thinks he thinks hes Luke Perry..oohh its creepy...7.... Randy said it was good some pitch problems...Paula said it was a good week for you...Whatever...Simon said it was a mistake, the singer of that song had charisma and personality and whiny....He is right..Horrible...Once again it is not a model show its singing..He is a good looking guy with a weak voice...

Robby....Drag Racer..Singing Hot Blooded...Not sure yet, the start was weak...I am on the fence..Guy has a good voice, not a great voice...Song has no energy, does not stand out..7.5...Randy said it was one of his favorite song but said you did not have that rock voice..He is no Daughtry..Randy did not say that I did..Paula said nothing...played it safe..Simon said the vocal was ok..

Danny Noriega up next..This kid is a creepy metro..Oh God..Walking out slowly and singing Don't you remember you told me you loved me baby....His voice is ok not great its creepy, the hair the girly voice, and no relevance,,,,6....Randy laughed again said there was problems with the song..said let it go..Paula said you are amazing..nothing ..Simon..Said it was not fantastic but better than last week, said you standout and look terriffic..

David Hernandez...Papa was a rolling stone..Better than last week...So far the strongest voice of the night..Lacks the soul to sing the song but he did a good job..I am not sure so I will give him an ...8.5.....Best of the night s far but not fantastic..Randy said this is the David we fell in love with..Randy said it was hot...Paula said it is pure and was amazing...Simon said it was the best vocal of the night..so far..read ahead..says you take criticism well...See how good I am..I really should be making a million a year and do this for a living..

Jason up next strange Pauly Walnutz hair..Seems pretty even keeled in his pre piece...Doobie Bros...Without Love...once again the guys can sing the songs but they do not control the songs...Its Doobie light...wow just lame creepy...7....Randy said it was pitchy and did not get it...Paula said it was not many notes that show something..Simon said last week was boring and this week was ordinary and it was like he was drunk at a party and it was corny...Not your American idol..guy said we are all killer singers..No your not dude...That was funny..He is saying that he has all the things that he really does not have..Says he has range, have not seen it..

See this is the problem. They keep 12 of each gender..It really should have been 4 and 20..Guys being the 4..Vote off the 4 worst each week..then you have a fair game. These guys are so bad with the exception of two after tonight..

Chickeeze...Not sure what song it is..He does have a strong voice....this is a good song for him i have no idea what song it is...His voice is good and strong..Maybe it was nerves last week..Best performance of the night...9...Randy said you are back...Said it was blazin and hot..Agreed..Paula said it was brilliant...Simon said it was great and I got a phone call in the middle..I missed some of it..

David Cook...plays the guitar lefty..Not many do..Too much playing and not much singing..Alright now is the song..Voice is better than most tonight but not great...Hokey in parts.....8.6.....Randy laughed again and then said he loved that he threw the pics out...said you are the real rocker and smart choice of songs..Paula said the back up band is on fire...Simon said David it was solid...but he is boring..and no charisma and now Simon is shooting back to his smart mouth..

David A...Imagine..Great song...Wow, this is the first wow performance...of this season...This is your american idol guy...He has a strong voice....10....Best performance of the night...Randy said it was one of the best vocals of the show...mature for your age...said it was hot..Paula said something nutz... said it was beautiful..Simon said it was risky doing the song was risky and now you are the one to beat after that...He is right...no other guy can compare to David A...He is goofy but they are right..Song gave me the chills a bit..So far the best in this season....

There are only three guys that guys that should move on...Dave A, Dave H, and Chekeezee at this point..Everyone else sucks