Well both the boys and girls are singing together tonight. Ryan introducing the new set at the Kodak Theatre? The band is in the air? That is gonna make for some wierd sounds..And a fake mosh pit..Do not think I agree with Asia going last week..But it happens..They sing one song tonight and its all about the Beatles...Randy said they put the song down those Beatle boys..Paula says sing it straight it will be good but if you change it have your game on..Simon gave Ryan a duh since he asked a dumb question..
Sayeesha.....Got to get you into my life...Might be a bad choice for her....Started off lost and rough...I am not sure about this one..Not a great song for her..Her voice gets lost in the lower registers and she has this one note she holds out for and then its a little flat...Its a much different version so she gets credit for that so I give her an 8.5....Randy said it started rough, by the middle it got better...Paula said you are a very good singer and it was pitchy at first...Simon said it was better than alright..said it was a good choice of song and you looked nervous and much better than last week..
I think who ever does Norweigan Wood, Fool on the Hill, a slow version of Day in the life, Yesterday, Long and winding road..Amanda should do Helter Skelter
Chekeezie...Ok way too much talk...She's a Woman...Oh God he is doing the sitting down thing..Doing a blue grass version..Very original..Possible dark horse..Has the crowd going..I think he should have stayed all blue grass but it is a very good job..9...Not to a familiar with the song..Randy said the arrangement was dope and he smashed it...Paula said you started with this O brother vibe and it paid off etc etc..Simon said I am surprised that I have to agree with these two..Said you looked like you changed and I thought you were terrific.
Ramielle...She is Soy Cute..The whole family are midgets..She is such a pretty girl...In My Life..Good choice of song..Here we go...On the staircase...She has great control over her chords...Oh God the mosh pit has been trained to do things..I hate that...She is hitting every chord but it is a little slow...Now she is opening it up...That was a perfect song..One of the best of thre night...9.....Disney good...Randy said boring, it laid there..Paula said you look pretty...Said it was pretty safe and she needs to step it up..Simon said he was bored to tears, from the standing on the stairs to the song that did nothing for her...I expect much more from you cause you are better..
Jason Castro....If I Fell...Good choice....Playing the guitar I think this kid is a true artist out of all of them...Sounds like that one group in the 90's ...Forget their name...Not energetic but good..I like...8.5....Randy said liked it not loved it, said the switches confused him..Paula said she disagrees....She feels his heart and thaet is special...Simon said last week you were incredible but tonight a student in a bedroom at midnite and it was boring..Good enough to stay in until next week...
Up next is Carly...Come Together....I do not like the song that much..She sings it well..She said she is going to change it but she has not...She sang it perfect until the end where she was screaming...9....Randy said you were strong and confident and said it was great. Paula said something..Simon said you picked the right song and that it reminds me about Kelly Clarkson
David Cook....Elenor Rigby...ouch..flat and slow at first...thinks he is Daughtry with hair...His voice is not strong and it sounds muffled but people are going to think it is a great song cause of the lights...I just dont get it...8....People are going for the look not the content...Randy said you can rock out...said there was pitch problems..do this you got this..Paula said you are good...Simon said he thought it was brilliant..I do not get that...
Brooke White....Let It Be..Good song choice for her.....Playing the piano...I like the instruments thing..messed up a word in song..just the piano at first but the band is coming in at the end...very solid performance...never got out from behind the piano and you do not see her that much..Good job ...9....Randy said not your strongest performance but bery heartfelt...Paula said this is your niche...Simon said it was again one of the best performances of the night, a brilliant choice of songs..She is crying
David Hernandez waving from the birds nest before going to break..He probably wants to dance for everyone if you know what I mean. Saw you Standing there...God he is out in the audience..Too much running around and he hit some pitch problems because he was running around. It comes off way too cheesey...I never really got this song and I guess why we see why the beatles can only cover it...7.5...Randy said you have a big voice and said it was overdone...Paula said it was overdone and scale it back...Simon said No NO NO said it was corny and not cool..Not a strong performance..Agreed.
Amanda...looking like a cat again...You cant do that....I like it.Good song choice for her weak voice...she does a good job belting it out and screaming...Have to say one of the better performances of the night...9...Did a nice job in making the song hers...Randy said you took a beatle song and rocked it out and I loved it...Paula..everyone is having fun to Paula...Simon said it was not as good as last week...shouty..said it is a good thing cause you are fresh but week over week not as good as last week...
I love the snake charmer commercial with Kelly Clarkson
Mike Johns....Just hate this guy..Across the Universe..Good song..Starts across acoustic...His mouth looks like David Bowie's when he sings...I just do not like his voice..Its not distinctive, but he is doing a good job with this song...Just too safe of a song...7.5...Not good for me but they are going to love it....Randy said waiting for something good to happen but it did not...Paula said something that made no sense..Simon said he agrees with Randy. Said he you are not singing below your ability. I agree
Christy Lee....8 Days A Week..Country style...Sounds like she is in love with Simon...Wow very different.Much different sound but very original...It may be better slower..It is a really good idea but it is moving tooo fast for her but I have to say very original..That could be a hit done just a little different..7.5....Randy said he liked the idea but he is torn...Paula said she did not like it, did not get it...Simon said it was bad...very brave but foolish...I do not agree with him..It just had to be a little slower...She may be going home...
Closing out the show, Idol front runner David Archuletta...We Can Work It Out...Forgot the words at the beginning and it is ruining the whole song..His voice is good and yet he befuddled right now...Brought it home at the end..how do you score this.....Voice was great but messed up...Still think he did good...8....Randy said I like your voice and but it did not work...Paula said something...Simon said that was a mess, he expects incredible performances and yet it was his weakest....
No comments:
Post a Comment