Tuesday, March 25, 2008

American Idol-And then there were 10

Well. I missed blogging about AI last week, and I will ask my three readers is there anything more gay I could have done? Answer Yes. I went and saw My Fair Lady at the NJPAC. Hahaha.

Theme tonight. A song from the year they were born..

Ramielle up first......Alone from Heart...What year was she born..Starts off very pitchy..She like a singing midget..wow she is off and flat and yelling...Its just such a bad song choice...Better towards the end, but she is not your American idol....7....Randy said I hear you are sick..said not the right song choice...Pitchy all over the place..Paula...said your voice something sick....She started to cry..As Simon began to talk she put her head down..Said he did not think it was all that bad and you will make it through.. She is really pretty...

Up next....Jason....1987..Damn...Fragile..Sting.. Playing the guitar...he is doing a good job..He knows how to pick a song that does not challenge him enough but will keep him in the mix...8...Randy said..he loves that song, good choice, said did not do too much vocally but it was nice..Paula..you are staying true to you..Saw nothing different so you are playing it safe...Simon said you had two bad weeks and it is time you take it more seriously..sorry....said it was clumsy and too much in your own world...

Syesha..1987...If I were your woman...Little Whitney..gotta bring it Syesha...so far so good Her voice sounds really good and full tonight..and strong, wow she hit every chord and every note in key and loud but not over modulated....9.5..one of the best in the show so far this year....Randy said...Its a good moment and the best you have ever sung..stellar and he was shocked...Paula said what is great is that where you flipped it you were fantastic....Simon said..it was the best so far but he did not think the end was the best...that girl did brought it...

I am actually watching it again since I now have a gift from Christ ..DVR..I actually think that was the inscription on the cross above his head

Chekeezie EZ...1985...If Only For One Night...Not sure what song it is..Pitchy at first but getting into a groove here...Flat in the middle...If you have to compare him to someone it would be Reuben but his voice is not that good. Pitchy in some parts during the middle and it lacks something..ending is better...8...Randy said it seemed old and he did not love it, not hip and cool and boring..Paula said she does not agree, said it was a great job..Simon said...sang it well but performance was cheesy...you have to show that you are original..song had no personality..

Brooke......Police....Every Breath you take...Messed it up at first...Piano nice take but they are gonna say she is hiding behind the piano...I don't understand why start off playing the piano and then bring the band in..Play it one way...not loving it but she is doing well...8..Randy said great song choice, loved that you messed it up but said when she got to the bridge did not like it..Lose the band see what I said..Paula said it was better than last week..She used the word niche again..Simon said just stay with the piano..Good enough to keep you in for another week..First half good even with the mistake second half no...

Mike Johns....Lame ass poser with his stupid stories...Queen...We will rock you..Come on...Cheese dick..Just to get the crowd on its feet...His voice is not strong and now thinks he will go the Konstantine route..I think he thinks he is God...I think he thinks he just rose from the dead last Sunday...This is a lame song and he is yelling and the girls love it...7...
Randy said yo yo dog..it was great and the best performance for me..Paula said this is your right song..Its your moment..Simon...first time with you I saw star potential...best performance of the night..no way..

Carly...Total Eclipse of the Heart..Good choice for her..This Irish chick can sing..in tune and no pitch problems..the version was too fast....9...she was blowing at the end..and she sung well too..Randy said....Interesting song choice....not good...not a good song choice..Paula said something...Simon said something did not work..did not enjoy it well..said you were uptight or something....

David Archuletta.....This kid always looks stunned..1990..OMG Not sure what song it is...It is bad in the low register...like he cannot hear the music...Its almost like it takes him a few seconds to get into the song..I do not know how to rate this song since I cannot compare it to anything...8... Randy said it was a strange choice but you can sing, don't know the song..Paula said she did not know the song..Simon said you sang well in parts and he did not like the performance and it was like a theme park performance and there are dancing animated creatures...

Christy Lee..She should have been gone a few weeks ago...God Bless The USA...Going for the votes of the people in the middle of the country..Its easy to hoodwink them..I have to say that she gets a bad rap but she can sing a bit...very country but solid..Nothing original and she gets knocked down when she does and will get knocked down for this but she did a good job..She sang each note well and strong...8.5..Randy said it was a little pitchy but good and good choice..Paula said it was good and your voice is much stronger...Simon said your best performance by a mile and best song choice and performance in years....

David Cook to close.. I am not a big fan of this guy..One of those guys that I just do not understand him...More about image than singing like Mike Johns....1982...Thin haired MFer...Singing Billie Jean but he is doing the Chris Cornell version..See he steals the whole concept..I just dont like him for this reason...He is going to pass it off like his own..Its an easy song for him to sing... 8.5...Sang it well but it was a stolen concept...Randy said you are the most original...said you are the winner..come on nothing about that be original..Paula said you are smart and strong and something...Simon said it was brave and it was amazin....He did do it well but it was so far from original

Mike or Jason should go

No comments: