AI

Katy Stevens...Kelly Clarkson Breakaway...FLAT...The whole song...Then sharp...She took an exciting song and dumbed it down..6...Not a good way to start..Randy said the song was too big for you and it did not work..Ellen said with her eyes wide open and you are great and young and I did not feel you...WHAT...Kara said you have a great radio voice..We have people who know themselves and those who dont..You dont but you are going to be a huge story..WHAT.... Simon said it is confusing...You have been given advice you have taken and its a problem...Its not working and you sucked the energy out of it...

Siobahn...House of the Rising Sign...So far so good..Nice tone and pitch..Slow and then some add ins..They are all gonna like this..9...Randy said you always take risks and you know Im a fan dude dog..Ellen said I know that house, you are why I love music because you move me..Kara loved it and she is surprised by her...Simon did not like..

Casey or Lacey...The Story....She sounds ok but too much muggin for the camera...boring...not bad..8...Randy said yo, whats cool but boring and sleepy but good performance...Ellen said it was good and perfect...Kara said you got here because of this...Simon said he did not love love the song but it sounded good...

Kaitlynn...Carole King...I feel the earth move...Eh...not a good choice but once again she is singing it well...she should have just played it slower and by herself on the piano...8...Randy said yo the hair is good but no connection bu the vibe was not there, not special...Ellen made reference to her guitar...Not a good choice of song..Not enough...Kara felt like she was not competing but just going through the motions and she is missing and not playing and what happened..Simon said I like you hair..On the downside it was request night sounding..sorry

Dee Dee...Bella Dona..She has a very distinctive voice..Updated a great song, not huge but not a bad job..I liked it.....she does have soul...9...Randy said Yo and said it was better than last week...Said it was not wow..Ellen said yes in dee dee dee dee..Like what you did with it..Kara said one of my faves for the season..Simon said I agree with Kara..Thought it was the best so far tonight...and it was a wow moment it was well balanced and a brilliant choice of song...

Paige....Smile....What the hell...Too old of a song...She can sing though so it should be good..Nice control of her voice but the song is putting everyone to sleep it has to get moving...she did a nice job just bad choice..8... Randy said I love that song but it was way too big..Ellen said it was sad and heavy...Kara agreed...It was all wrong...Simon said it was horrible choice and arrangement was bad...you have a great voice but no idea who you are and it may cost you...

Crystal...Good..9...One of the best girls...Randy said this is what the show is about..Ellen said great..Kara said now i see what the record will be..Simon said you are going to be in the top 12..Improved

Lilly Scott up last singing some Patsy..I fall to pieces...Eeeekkk not a great Patsy song..Not doing a bad job, her lower register was rough but it is coming back...The end was huge....She is one of the girls that knows who she is..9....Randy said it was hot and you are in the zone..ellen said love your voice love you..Kara said you made Patsy feel current..Simon said you are very brave with that song on this night..It did not have the wow...